Repertory
What is a rubric in homeopathy?
By Dr. Harish Kumar · November 20, 2026 · 5 min read
A rubric is a symptom as the repertory words it, together with the remedies known to produce or cure it and how strongly each one does. Here is how to read one, and why your own words are not yet a rubric.
A rubric is a symptom written in the repertory's own words, together with the list of remedies known to produce or cure that symptom, and a grade showing how strongly each remedy is associated with it. It is the unit the repertory is built from. Kent's Repertory of the Homoeopathic Materia Medica (1897) contains 68,739 of them; Bönninghausen's Therapeutic Pocket-Book (1891) contains 2,718.
That one-line definition will get you through a viva. The rest of this page is what it actually means when you have a patient in front of you.
The anatomy of a rubric
Take this entry:
MIND — ANXIETY — night
Three things are stacked there.
The chapter. MIND. Kent sorts the whole body into chapters — Mind, Vertigo, Head, Eye, Ear, Nose, Face, Mouth, Throat, Stomach, Abdomen, Rectum, Urine, Genitalia, Larynx, Respiration, Cough, Chest, Back, Extremities, Sleep, Chill, Fever, Perspiration, Skin, Generalities. You cannot find a rubric without first deciding which chapter the symptom belongs to, and that decision is already a clinical judgement.
The rubric. ANXIETY. This is the symptom in the book's language, not the patient's.
The sub-rubric. night. A qualification — a time, a modality, a location, a concomitant, an extension. Sub-rubrics nest several levels deep: MIND — ANXIETY — night — midnight — after. Each level down is narrower and carries fewer remedies.
Under that heading sits the remedy list, and this is the part that matters:
Acon., ARS., Bell., Calc., Carb-v., Phos., Puls., Rhus-t., Sulph.
The typography is not decoration. It is a grade.
Grades: how strongly the remedy belongs there
A grade records how confident the repertory's compilers were that this remedy produces or cures this symptom — drawn from provings, from cured cases, and from clinical experience.
Kent uses three degrees. Third degree (printed in bold capitals) means the symptom appeared repeatedly in provings and was confirmed by cures. Second degree (italics) is well attested. First degree (ordinary type) is recorded once or twice, or clinically only.
Bönninghausen uses four, which is why his Pocket-Book cannot simply be merged into Kent's and read as one book. A fourth-degree mark in Bönninghausen does not mean the same thing as a third-degree mark in Kent, and flattening the two scales into one destroys information. On HomeopathyWorld the two books are searched together but each keeps its own scale.
When you repertorise, those grades are what get added up. A remedy appearing in three rubrics at third degree outranks one appearing in five rubrics at first degree — which is the whole reason a repertorisation is not a vote count.
Your words are not yet a rubric
This is the step most students skip, and it is where marks are lost in the practical.
A patient says: "I can't sleep, I keep thinking about my exams, and I feel worse the moment I lie down."
None of that is a rubric. It is raw material. Converting it means deciding:
- Is the sleeplessness the complaint, or is the anxiety? That decides the chapter.
- "Thinking about my exams" — is that
MIND — ANXIETY — anticipationorMIND — THOUGHTS — persistent? They are different rubrics with different remedy lists. - "Worse the moment I lie down" is a modality, and a good one —
aggravation, lying down.
Two competent homeopaths will not always choose the same rubric, and that is fine. What is not fine is picking a rubric whose wording does not actually match what the patient said. The repertory's language is nineteenth-century and translated from German: diarrhoea is spelled with the ligature, coryza means a cold in the nose, lachrymation means watering eyes, fainting appears under Generalities rather than where you expect. Searching for your word and finding nothing usually means the book calls it something else — not that the symptom is absent.
Rubric, symptom, remedy: keeping them straight
These three get muddled in vivas.
- A symptom is what the patient experiences and reports.
- A rubric is that symptom as the repertory words it, plus the remedies under it.
- A remedy appears in many rubrics, at different grades in each.
So a rubric is a lookup from one symptom to many remedies; the Materia Medica runs the other way, from one remedy to many symptoms. You need both, and they are not substitutes. A repertory tells you which remedies to consider. A Materia Medica tells you whether the one you chose actually fits the person.
The three mistakes to avoid
Taking too many rubrics. Every rubric you add drags in remedies that merely happen to be listed there. Five well-chosen rubrics beat fifteen loose ones; a wide general rubric such as headache adds almost no discriminating power because it contains most of the Materia Medica.
Taking rubrics that are too narrow. A sub-rubric four levels deep may hold only two remedies, and if the correct one was never proved for that exact qualification, you have excluded it before you began.
Ignoring the grade. A remedy present in first degree only is a weak signal. Students who count appearances rather than reading grades consistently arrive at the wrong top remedy.
The balance Hahnemann asks for is in §153: it is the striking, singular, uncommon and peculiar symptoms that should decide, while general, vague complaints "demand but little attention". Choose rubrics that individualise this patient, not rubrics that would fit anyone with the same diagnosis.
Looking rubrics up
Both repertories are public domain and both are on HomeopathyWorld. About 2,000 of the most useful rubrics are published as ordinary web pages, readable without an account, each listing every remedy with its grade. The full 71,457 are searchable inside the app, where you can weight a rubric, mark one eliminating, and see the arithmetic behind the ranking rather than just the result.
If you are revising for the IV BHMS Repertory and Case Taking practical, the useful drill is not memorising rubrics. It is taking a case you have already seen, writing down the patient's words, and then converting each one into a rubric and justifying the choice out loud. That conversion is what the examiner is actually testing.
Dr. Harish Kumar
Homeopath and founder of HomeopathyWorld. Writes on materia medica, case-taking, repertory and the Organon for students and practitioners.
Put this into practice
Repertorise these symptoms against the real Kent & Bönninghausen, read the full Materia Medica, and practise the case on an AI patient — free account, no card required.
Create your free accountMore in Repertory
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
No comments yet — start the conversation.